Many emotional and poignant movies revolve around
significant events, such as war (Life Is Beautiful)
or overcoming an injustice (Remember The Titans).
These events concern not only the main characters
of the film, but have a large impact on the rest
of the community. Broken Wings is not such
a film. Instead, it centers on how the unexpected
death of a husband and father, perhaps a quiet
event to the rest of world, causes important consequences
to the five family members he left behind.
The movie opens with the teenage girl Maya (Maron)
rehearsing with her band during the Young Bands’
Competition. She calls her mother (Banay)
to let her know how things are going, only to
discover that her mother has been called in to
work and she must come home immediately to baby-sit
her younger siblings Ido (Daniel Magon)
and Bahr (Eliana Magon). No matter that
the band is about to go on stage, and that the
rest of the members are dependent on her. Maya
is torn between loyalty to her friends and to
her family, but her sense of responsibility wins,
and she takes off on her bike.
Thus begins our glimpse into the life of sacrifice
that the Ulman family has to accept since the
sudden and unexpected death of the man in their
lives. As the oldest of four children, Maya essentially
becomes the second parent, preparing lunches and
making sure everyone is dressed and ready for
school. This duty is especially heavy for Maya
because her mother Dafna, a midwife at the local
hospital, must now work extra shifts to compensate
for the loss of income. Dafna is constantly tired,
and though she tries the best she can, she cannot
manage to bring the family together.
The rest of the family responds in different
ways. The eldest son Yair (Gvirtz), still
struggling with anger at his father’s abandonment,
retreats into the belief that his life is just
a speck of dust in the universe and nothing matters.
He stops going to school, alienates his girlfriend,
and dons a giant mouse mask to roam the subways
and streets incognito. Younger son Ido deals with
his emotions through art, sketching and videotaping
himself. Youngest child Bahr seeks attention from
her family, only to find that they are all busy
coping with their own problems.
In the midst of this, Ido takes a severe fall
which sends him to the hospital. For the rest
of the film we observe how each member of the
family handles this new crisis—whether it
brings him or her closer to the family, or serves
as a breaking point. Although the entire film
is heartrending, the last third is especially
powerful. Credit should be given to the cast for
their wide display of emotional portrayals, and
it already has, with Banai and Maron both receiving
Israeli Film Academy Awards for their acting.
Though the emotions are realistic, the film can
sometimes feel contrived and too “written.”
For example, when Maya leaves the band competition,
she is still wearing her costume—a pair
of mesh wings—and by the time she arrives
home, one of them is broken. There are also the
frequent happenstance meetings between Dafna and
Dr. Goldman (Freedman) at the hospital,
who always seems to appear when Dafna is in trouble,
to rescue her. These and other such moments are
a reminder that this is a scripted movie, and
they detract from the film’s ability to
submerge the audience in the Ulmans’ world.
Broken Wings is in Hebrew with English
subtitles.
—Kelly Hsu