It burns my ass when bands prematurely release "Best of"
records. Groups with one, maybe two good records kick out a best of
package like they've been at the game for years. Now, I know that
"best of" packages are generally perpetuated by either a
need for money, record contract obligations, ego, or publicity for
a new release
. I'd say in the case of The Vines, it's
money, ego and the July release of their fourth album, Melodia.
Three out of four ain't bad.
Before I'm burned at the stake for blasphemy by Vines fans everywhere,
I want to say that I really liked Highly Evolved when it was
released in 2002. The Vines were one of the best bands of the garage
rock movement that was happening at the time; I was really into the
raw, self produced sound of many of the bands. Although I must say
that The White Stripes were, and still are, my favorite of
the bunch.I was comfortable with Highly Evolved, the album
seemed very familiar then it hit me, " Half of this album sounds
like Nirvana and the other half comes on like a never before
released Beatles' record." My two all-time favorite bands
in one disc. Kickass! But imitation is the sincerest form of a lack
of originality and sadly, The Vines are far from original. . Where
Nirvana, The Beatles and The Kinks (the three bands most heavily
pillaged by The Vines) made their impact was their ability to take
a bit of something that came before them and then morph it into something
revolutionary and entirely their own. Craig Nichols, lead vocals/guitar
even took the Vines' name from a band his father had in the 1960's.
Although to Craig's credit, his dad's band was spelled Vynes.
Although unoriginal, there are good songs on Best Of The Vines.
"Get Free" "Highly Evolved" "Outtathaway",
"Animal Machine" and "Ride" are all exceptional
rockers in the grand old early 1990's tradition, whereas "Factory"
"Autumn Shade" and "Sunchild" have a mellow, spaced
out feel that would have made them right at home on any psychedelic
record in the 1960's. The long and short of it is, if you miss the
sound that made Seattle famous and melodies that made Liverpool a
place to be, than Best Of The Vines is for you. If you're looking
for something fresh and innovative, then the Best Of or The
Vines as a band for that matter, are far from your best options.
-Danny R. Phillips
Check out more
e-mail the chief
Like this article?
it to a friend!